If you’ve spent any time around trading communities, you’ve likely experienced the firehose of conflicting advice. One day you’re told to size up, the next day you’re reminded to stick to your process. Should you be expanding your playbook or narrowing your focus? Should you model others or lean into your unique strengths?
The truth is, not all advice is wrong — it’s just not always right for where you are.
Every trader progresses through different stages, each requiring a different focus. Understanding where you stand in this journey helps clarify what you should be working on, what to ignore, and how to move forward effectively.
Below is how I personally define the six core stages of a trader’s development. Think of it as a flexible map — not a rigid formula — but one that can provide structure as you navigate this challenging yet deeply rewarding path.
Stage 1: The Newbie – Learning the Rules of the Game
Everyone starts here.
As a total beginner, your main goal is exposure. You’re not here to trade — you’re here to absorb. Learn how the markets function, how orders are placed, what the bid-ask spread means, and how different economic events impact price movement. Understand your trading software. Memorize the basics of technical analysis. Get a grip on sector relationships, halt rules, and market mechanics.
At this stage, you should not be trading live. Capital risk is a distraction from the learning process. You’re building your foundation. Watch tape. Read. Take beginner courses. Ask questions. Your number one job is to act like a sponge — open-minded and hungry.
For full-time new traders, this initial education phase might last just a few intense weeks. For part-timers, it can take months. And that’s okay.
Stage 2: The Trainee – Building Process & Market Awareness
Once you’ve got the basics down, it’s time to start thinking like a trader.
Now you’re showing up every day with intention. You’re learning to identify the handful of tickers actually “in play” each day — the stocks that matter. You’re building a repeatable routine: scanning, journaling, cataloging charts, and starting to build your highlight reel of great setups.
Here, you may begin light live trading — but with extremely small size. Think: one share. The point is not profit. The point is interaction. Begin experimenting with entries and exits. Learn from others. Mimic their strengths. Absorb their habits. Keep your ego out of it.
PNL doesn’t matter. What does? Reps. Structure. Reflection. Discipline.
This stage can take years. And that’s still okay.
Stage 3: The Novice – Developing a Playbook & Finding Your Edge
At this stage, you’ve put in enough reps to start seeing patterns — not just in charts, but in yourself.
You’re now building your own playbook. Not just screenshots, but detailed documentation of your best trades. You’re narrowing down the strategies that make the most sense to you and beginning to identify your “easy money” setups — the trades that feel intuitive and give you the best edge.
Live trading becomes more consistent. You’re still trading small, but you’re collecting data and getting real feedback. Risk management starts to matter more. This is where you introduce daily report cards to track progress on specific skills and behaviors.
You also start paying attention to nuance — the details that differentiate a decent trade from a great one.
Your goal here is to achieve consistency. If you can regularly cover your living expenses through trading alone, you’re ready for the next stage.
Stage 4: The Intermediate – Growth, Refinement, and Sizing Up
This is one of the most exciting and rewarding phases. You’re finally making money, and you’ve got proof of concept. But now the real work begins.
At this level, your goal is twofold:
- Push size on your proven strategies.
- Refine and expand your playbook strategically.
Here’s the rule of thumb:
- If your core strategies are still providing opportunity, double down and refine them.
- If the market slows or those setups dry up, then and only then should you explore new strategies.
You’re no longer asking basic questions — you’re analyzing performance with intention. You’ve formed productive habits, and the trader lifestyle has taken root. You review tape regularly. You study your losses. You network with peers. You continue to track everything.
You’re not just a student of trading anymore — you’re a professional.
Stage 5: The Advanced Trader – Mastery and Mental Optimization
This is where the margins narrow and the details matter most.
You’re trading size now. You’ve built a robust system and have consistent profits. But at this level, the edge isn’t just in the charts — it’s in your head.
This is where trading psychology becomes the focal point. Tilt, hesitation, FOMO — these are the cracks that leak PNL and performance. You’re no longer just trading the market; you’re managing yourself.
It’s at this stage that I often recommend serious traders invest in a performance coach or trading psychologist. Small shifts in your mindset, confidence, or routine can unlock enormous returns.
You’ll also begin refining your setups to adapt to various market environments, including rare tail events. And through it all, you keep cutting out what doesn’t work, leaning hard into what does.
Stage 6: The Elite – Precision, Mastery, and Flow
Very few reach this stage.
Elite traders operate in a space that blends art and science. Their execution is fluid. Their mind is calm. Their daily routine is obsessively optimized for peak performance — sleep, diet, environment, habits.
Trading becomes a performance, and they are in flow most days.
These traders know exactly when to strike. They wait patiently for setups with sufficient liquidity for their size. Their bets are massive, yet disciplined. Most of their time is spent refining entries, improving precision, and eliminating inefficiencies.
Here, trading is no longer about money. It’s about mastery. About discovering the full extent of your potential. It’s a personal challenge to see what’s possible when all of your skills — mental, physical, strategic — align in perfect rhythm.
Final Thoughts
The path of a trader is deeply personal. There’s no one-size-fits-all strategy. But understanding the stages of the journey can give you direction, purpose, and clarity.
Whether you’re just starting out or on the brink of professional success, the secret is this:
Know where you are. Honor it. Then do the work that stage demands.
Trading rewards the patient, the disciplined, and the endlessly curious. Keep showing up. Keep evolving. The journey is long — but if you’re in it for the right reasons, it’s worth every step.
P.S. If you’re having trouble, you might want to get a mentor, learn more here!
